A 17-year-old boy presented with persistent swelling and ptosis of the eyelid after blunt injury. Histologic examination revealed a clinically unsuspected traumatic neuroma. Ptosis and the traumatic neuroma persisted despite two eyelid operations. Traumatic neuroma is rare after blunt trauma; it has not been previously reported in the eyelid. It is important to identify this lesion because complete excision may help to prevent recurrence.