Recent studies of temporal resolution in hearing‐impaired listeners indicate that many ears with cochlear damage exhibit elevated temporal gap thresholds. The deviations from normal may be large, for equivalent‐SPL comparisons, but are often small or absent for equivalent‐SL comparisons. In the present experiment, we examine the premise that SL effects in gap resolution are independent of sound pressure level. Normal hearing subjects used a Békésy procedure to track the minimum level of an octave‐band signal at 1 kHz needed to keep a periodic temporal gap at threshold. Performance functions were generated to show stimulus intensity as a function of gap duration, for gaps from 25 ms to the smallest detectable value. In separate conditions, the level of a white‐noise background was varied to shift the subject’s audibility threshold. Results indicate that the limits of resolution are largely invariant with SPL, but criterion sensation levels for resolution are progressively reduced at higher SPL. It is concluded that gap thresholds from normal and impaired ears should be compared for equivalent SPL; comparisons made with SL equated are likely to underestimate the consequence of cochlear damage on resolving capacity.