This paper considers some problems in the probabilistic analysis of physical evidence in criminal investigations. Two basic assumptions are made: (1) That the number of persons or objects possessing a particular set of properties can be considered as a random variable, and (2) that it is possible to estimate the probability function of this random variable. Two models (one with and one without the assumption that the suspect is a random selection from the set of possible suspects) which are applicable to the evaluation ofpartial transfer evidence—an important category of physical evidence that is found in most criminal investigations—are developed. A detailed analysis of the models and an example are presented for the case when the estimated probability distribution is binomial with an expected value less than 1. As the expected value becomes smaller, the assumption of randomness in the selection of the suspect becomes immaterial to the evaluation of the evidential significance.