Silica and ferric oxide are common industrial exposures. Studies have indicated that all commonly occurring forms of crystalline silica can cause fibrotic lung disease. There is evidence to indicate that crystalline silica is carcinogenic in humans who have not developed silicosis, while amorphous silica is not carcinogenic in humans. An important biological response to particles deposited deep in the lung is their engulfment by pulmonary alveolar macrophages (AM). To assess the role of AM in silica‐induced lung disease, particle size distribution and surface area of crystalline, gelled, precipitated, and fumed silica, ferric oxide, and aluminum oxide were characterized; the cytotoxicity of the particles to hamster and rat AM in vitro was measured at 0.0–0.5 mg/1 x 106cells at 24 and 48 h using dye exclusion procedures. The count medium diameter for aluminum oxide, ferric oxide, and amorphous silica was equal to or less than 0.38 μm, while for crystalline silica the value was 0.83 μm. The surface areas for the amorphous silicas and the aluminum oxide ranged from 253 to 125 m2lg with gelled silica having the highest value; the values for crystalline silica and ferric oxide were 4.3 and 10.8 m2/g, respectively. Crystalline silica (1.6%) was detected in the fumed silica, while none was detected in precipitated or gelled silica. With gelled silica, based on the dose of the particle, the viability of the hamster AM decreased to 27% at 0.05 mg and to zero at 0.1 mg at 24 h. At doses of 0.05 and 0.1 mg of crystalline, precipitated, or fumed silica, the percent viability decreased significantly to 76–67% and 51–42%, respectively, and to zero at 0.5 mg. Macrophages viable at 24 h decreased further at 48 h compared with the control culture. The ferric oxide and the aluminum oxide showed minimal to no changes in viability. Similar results for the particles were obtained with rat AM. The results indicate that precipitated and fumed amorphous silica tested at equivalent doses are equally as toxic to AM lavaged from two species of rodents as crystalline silica; gelled silica is more toxic than crystalline. Ferric oxide and aluminum oxide are noncytotoxic in this system. The results of this study indicate that the dose as well as the surface area and surface characterization are important determinants in the cytotoxicity of hamster and rat AM to these particles.