This study investigated the frequency specificity of the auditory brainstem (ABR) and middle latency (MLR) responses to 500- and 2000-Hz brief tones using narrow-band derived response analyses of the responses recorded in high-pass masking noise [Oates and Stapells, J. Acoust. Soc. Am.102, 3597–3608 (1997)]. Stimuli were linear- and exact-Blackman-gated tones presented at 80 dB ppe SPI. Cochlear contributions to ABR waveV-V′and MLR wave Na-Pa were assessed by response amplitude profiles as a function of derived band center frequency. The largest amplitudes of waves V and Na-Pa occurred in the 500- and 707-Hz derived bands in response to the exact-Blackman- and linear-gated 500-Hz tones. The peak in the response amplitude profiles for wave V to both 2000-Hz stimuli was seen in the 2000-Hz derived band. For wave Na-Pa, the maxima in the amplitude profiles occurred in the 2000- and 1410-Hz derived bands for the exact-Blackman- and linear-gated tones. Smaller cochlear contributions to the ABR/MLR were also present at 0.5–1 octave above and below the nominal stimulus frequencies. The ABR/MLR to 500- and 2000-Hz 80 dB ppe SPL tones thus shows good frequency specificity, with no significant differences in the frequency specificity of: (1) ABR versus MLR; (2) these evoked potentials to 500- versus 2000-Hz tones; and (3) responses to exact-Blackman- versus linear-gated tones.