AbstractThe mechanisms whereby the normal pattern of muscles within the developing chick limb bud is generated are largely unexplored. It has been proposed that the muscle pattern is established independently of the pattern for the limb skeletal elements to which the muscles normally attach (Shellswell and Wolpert: “The Pattern of Muscle and Tendon Development in the Chick Wing.” In:Vertebrate Limb and Somite Morphogenesis. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 71–86, 1977). To further examine this possibility we studied the formation of the proximal wing muscles in normal andwinglesschick embryos. The muscles of the shoulder region (including the pectoralis) arise as part of the dorsal and ventral premuscle masses of the developing limb bud. These secondarily migrate out of the limb to take origin from the pectoral girdle while inserting onto the humerus (Sullivan:Aust. J. Zool., 10:458–516, 1962). With rare exceptions,winglessembryos have complete absence of wing skeletal elements, but they may possess more than 40% of the normal volume of wing‐bud‐derived muscles. The muscles that remain inwinglessembryos are primarily shoulder muscles, and to a varying extent, the pectoralis. The question we sought to answer was whether inwinglessembryos the proximal wing muscles could form a normal pattern in the absence of the humerus and distal wing skeletal elements. By examining three‐dimensional reconstructions of the proximal wing region in normal andwinglessembryos, we found that the initial subdivision of the dorsal and ventral premuscle masses proceeded normally in the absence of the wing skeleton. This resulted in a grossly normal pattern of proximal wing muscles despite the absence of wing skeletal elements. However, some subsequent cleavages of individual muscles within premuscle mass divisions did not occur inwinglessembryos. This suggests that the skeleton may be required for this step in muscle morphogenesis to occur. We also observed that the wing‐budderived muscles inwinglessembryos were nearly always anchored to the pectoral girdle at both ends. Sometimes this resulted in muscles making abnormal tendonous fusions with other muscles derived from the opposite (i.e., dorsal or ventral) premuscle mass. Therefore, attachment to the skeleton may be important for some facet of muscle development. Finally, the supracoracoideus muscle was absent in all but onewinglessembryo we examined in the present study. In that one, it was substantially reduced in volume compared to normal. Despite the absence of this muscle, the space normally occupied by the supracoracoideus was maintained beneath the pectoralis. This observation suggests that the form, or shape, of a muscle may be established within the connective tissue in the absence of th