This paper presents the yield comparisons from a wide range of silvicultural regimes when applied to nineteen United States National Forests in the Pacific Northwest. The objective is to highlight the range of yield, value and biological parameters that result given any one of these regimes is followed over the next 100 years. Many non-forestry professionals are pressing for no harvest or selection-type all-aged forest harvesting regimes in the Pacific Northwest. The question is, that if these regimes do not provide comparable wood volumes to clear-cutting, the public continues to demand wood products, and the wildlife and plant biodiversity is permanently altered, “Is this where we want to go?”.